Choosing the right dog food is one of the most important decisions you can make for your furry friend’s health and wellbeing. With so many options on the market, it can be overwhelming trying to determine which formulas will provide your pup with the optimal nutrition.
This comprehensive 2023 guide to picking the healthiest dog food will walk you through everything you need to know. We’ll cover how to read labels, what ingredients to look for and avoid, decoding marketing claims, comparing brands and product lines, deciding on kibble vs wet food, understanding your dog’s needs, and much more.
After reading this extensively researched review, you’ll feel confident you’re making the best choice to fuel your dog’s unique nutritional requirements. Let’s dig in!
How to Choose A Healthy Dog Food
Check the Ingredient List
The single most important factor in evaluating any dog food is scrutinizing the ingredient list. By law, ingredients must be listed in order of weight. This allows you to easily see the main components.
Ideally, you want to see:
- Whole meat or fish in the first 2 ingredients – This indicates it’s packed with premium animal protein. Look for named sources like beef, chicken, salmon etc. Avoid generics like “meat meal”.
- Whole foods across the list – Ingredients should be recognizable foods like whole grains, legumes, fruits, veggies.
- No artificial preservatives – Steer clear of BHA, BHT, ethoxyquin. Natural preservatives like Vitamin E are better.
- No fillers – Avoid corn, wheat, soy which are hard to digest and low in nutrients.
- No by-products – By-products have questionable nutritional value.
- No added sugars – Sugars are added for palatability but unnecessary. They can promote obesity and diabetes.
Verify Nutritional Adequacy
The food should adhere to AAFCO standards, meaning testing proves it delivers complete and balanced nutrition. This confirmation will be stated on the label.
Select Appropriate Life Stage Formula
Puppies, adults and seniors all have unique nutritional requirements. Choosing an age-specific formula tailored to their needs is key.
Compare Calorie Content
Pay attention to calorie density, especially if your dog is less active or prone to weight gain. Opt for low-calorie foods to prevent obesity.
Consider Allergies and Sensitivities
If your dog has food allergies or intolerances like gluten sensitivity, carefully read labels to avoid problem ingredients. Limited ingredient diets may be best.
Examine Manufacturer Credibility
Research companies to ensure they use credentialed veterinary nutritionists to formulate diets and frequently perform feeding trials. This instills confidence in product quality.
Top 5 Healthiest Dog Food Brands
With an overwhelming array of dog food options on shelves today, it helps to know the most reputable brands recommended by vets for nutritious formulas:
- Nearly 50 years of experience creating science-backed breed and health-specific formulas
- Rigorous research with hundreds of feeding trials annually
- Manufacturing practices follow stringent quality and safety protocols
Hill’s Science Diet
- Formulated by 80+ PhD nutritionists and veterinarians
- Clinically proven to improve dog health issues
- Strict internal quality control standards exceed industry norms
Purina Pro Plan
- High protein formulas backed by years of research
- Trusted brand used by many professional dog trainers, handlers and breeders
- Numerous options for various breed sizes and health needs
- Developed in the 1950s by an animal nutritionist
- Proprietary fiber blends for digestion
- Affordable prices appeal to budget-conscious owners
- Focused on all-natural ingredients
- Cold-formed manufacturing preserves nutrients
- Veterinarian-developed formulas free of animal by-products
No matter which brand you choose, consult your vet if you have any concerns about your dog’s nutritional needs.
Dry Dog Food (Kibble) vs. Wet Food
One of the first decisions you’ll need to make is whether dry kibble or wet canned food is better for your pup. There are advantages and disadvantages to both.
Dry Dog Food
- Typically cheaper than wet food
- Helps clean teeth and reduce plaque
- Easy to measure out portions
- Convenient to store and serve
- Encourages chewing which eases boredom
- Higher carb content with less moisture
- More processed than wet foods
- Can lead to dehydration if sufficient water not provided
- Some dogs find it less palatable
Wet Dog Food
- Increased moisture keeps dogs hydrated
- Similar soft texture to a natural diet
- Makes it easy to add in other foods like raw meat
- Dogs tend to find it more enticing and appetizing
- Typically more expensive than kibble
- Spoils quickly once opened
- Bacteria can grow if left out
- Difficult to portion into meals
- Intense aroma may be overpowering
Most vets recommend feeding adult dogs a mix of both wet and dry options to balance out the pros and cons of each style. Puppies with developing teeth may benefit most from crunchy kibble.
Dog Food Ingredient Glossary
Learning key facts about common pet food ingredients will help you become a more informed shopper:
Meat Meals – Meat is cooked to remove moisture then dried into protein-rich meal. Quality varies greatly so best to look for specifics like chicken meal or lamb meal.
By-Products – Parts like intestines, feathers, hooves. Not harmful but have lower digestibility than muscle meats. Avoid if possible.
Fruits and Vegetables – Add vitamins, minerals and antioxidants. Choose whole sources like carrots, peas, apples. Stay away from high glycemic foods like potatoes.
Grains – Cheap fillers like corn, wheat and soy are linked to allergies. Opt for digestible grains like oatmeal, brown rice, quinoa.
Dairy – Typically added as yogurt for probiotics. Only add for dogs who tolerate milk. Can cause GI upset.
Oils – Excellent omega fatty acid sources like fish and coconut oil support skin, coat, cognitive function, and more.
Sweeteners – Added sugars and salt increase palatability but are unnecessary and unhealthy. Avoid foods containing these.
Reading labels closely and getting clarification on any confusing or questionable ingredients ensures you understand exactly what’s in the bag. Don’t hesitate to call manufacturers for more specifics on their formulas.
Decoding Dog Food Marketing Claims
Dog food labels today are filled with fancy-sounding buzz words and claims designed to entice consumers. But are they meaningful or just empty marketing hype? Here’s help decoding common advertising lingo:
Natural: No legal definition exists. Could still contain preservatives, artificial colors, additives. Focus on specific ingredients instead.
Organic: Must contain 95% certified organic ingredients. Good baseline but organic doesn’t always mean healthiest option.
Grain-Free: Often implies superior. Dogs tolerate many grains well. Key is choosing digestible whole grains like rice, barley.
Meat as first ingredient: Sounds appealing but ingredients are listed by weight before processing. Meats contain lots of moisture which is removed.
Holistic: Another vague, unregulated term. Verify actual ingredients promote whole body wellness.
No by-products: Better quality is muscle meat vs organ meats. But some organ meats like liver have nutrients.
Veterinarian recommended: True for major brands developed by credentialed vet nutritionists. But many brands fake this claim.
Made in the USA: Nice bonus but no guarantee of safety or quality on its own. Look beyond the marketing.
The most foolproof way to gauge any dog food is analyzing the label rather than putting stock in charming yet meaningless package promotions. Don’t pay more strictly for branding and clever language.
Dog Food Prices – Cheaper vs. Premium Costs
One significant factor affecting your dog food selection will be assessing your budget. Prices can range from under $1 per pound for generic store brands to over $6 per pound for ultra-premium lines. But does higher cost really mean better nutrition? Let’s break it down:
Cheap Dog Food
- Made with corn, soy, wheat filler
- Derive protein from plant instead of animal sources
- Use inexpensive by-products like bone meal
- Artificial colors, sugars added for taste
- Higher calorie counts make dogs feel full
- Lack optimal levels of fatty acids, vitamins
Potential Issues: Obesity, diabetes, malnutrition, GI distress
Premium Dog Food
- Feature quality identified meat as first ingredients
- Include healthy whole food carbohydrates like legumes, veggies
- Enhanced with probiotics, antioxidants, joint supplements
- Balanced nutrition based on research
- Lower calorie counts prevent overeating
- Higher cost reflects quality ingredients
Potential Benefits: Healthy weight, improved skin, coat, energy, joint mobility and more
The bottom line? Paying more upfront for a premium food with superior nutrition will likely save you money on vet bills in the long run while keeping your dog happier and healthier. But you can find quality foods at mid-range prices too by closely evaluating ingredients and company standards.
How Much and How Often to Feed Your Dog
Figuring out the optimal quantity, frequency and schedule for feeding your dog can be confusing. Here are some general guidelines:
Check manufacturer recommendations – The label will provide a feeding chart or calculation based on your dog’s weight to help tailor portion sizes. This is just a starting point.
Consider calories – Even within the same brand, formulas vary in calorie density. Factoring in activity level, opt for less calorie-dense foods if your dog is prone to obesity.
Weigh food – For accuracy, invest in a pet food scale to measure out portions rather than “eyeballing” volume amounts which can be misleading.
Monitor body condition – Feel your dog’s ribs and waist. You should be able to easily feel but not see ribs without excess sagging or fat cover. Adjust quantity as needed to maintain ideal weight.
Feed consistent schedule – Set scheduled mealtimes and avoid free-feeding food available at all times. This helps regulate metabolism.
Divide into two or three meals – Feeding smaller portions multiple times per day helps prevent gorging and indigestion.
Transition food gradually – When changing formulas, mix increasing amounts of new food with old to avoid GI upset.
Every dog has unique needs best assessed through trial and error. Work closely with your vet to tailor the optimal diet plan.
Best Dog Foods for Puppies
Choosing the right puppy food sets the course for lifelong health. Here’s how to select the top formulas for puppies under 12 months old:
- AAFCO approved – Ensures complete nutrition for growth and development. Avoid adult foods even if puppy eats with adult dogs.
- Quality protein – Look for meat or poultry as first ingredient. Minimum crude protein should be 22% for large breeds and 28% for small breeds.
- Fat for energy – Higher fat like 20% provides concentrated calories needed for growing puppies. Choose healthy fats from chicken, salmon, canola oil.
- Digestive support – Probiotics and prebiotics from yogurt, pumpkin and oats prevent upset stomachs.
- Glucosamine – Helps build healthy joints susceptible to injury during rapid growth periods.
- Omega fatty acids – DHA from fish oils boosts brain development.
- Calcium considerations – Excessive calcium from too-fast growth can harm skeletal development. Look for calcium minimums and phosphorus ratios ideal for large and small breeds.
- Multiple small meals – The high metabolism of puppies requires frequent nourishing. Feed at least 3 to 4 meals daily.
Top puppy food contenders that meet these needs include Orijen Puppy, Instinct Puppy, Canidae All Life Stages, Taste of the Wild High Prairie Puppy Formula and Wellness Complete Health Puppy.
Best Dog Foods for Senior Dogs
As dogs age, their nutritional demands change. Key considerations for selecting an optimal senior dog food include:
- Lower calorie – Seniors require up to 30% fewer calories to prevent unhealthy weight gain and obesity. Look for 286 kcal/cup or less in analysis.
- Increased fiber – Boost digestion regularity often sluggish in older dogs. Seek formulas with beet pulp, pumpkin.
- Extra protein – Counteract loss of lean muscle mass with minimum 18% protein from eggs, cottage cheese, meat.
- Glucosamine boost – Ease achy joints and arthritis which commonly afflict seniors.
- Antioxidant rich – Protect aging cells from damage. Look for veggies, berries, vitamins C, E.
- Omega fatty acids – Support skin, coat and heart health. Fish, flaxseed and canola oils are great sources.
- Probiotics – Maintain optimal gut and immune health more vulnerable with age.
Wellness Complete Health Senior, Blue Buffalo Life Protection Senior, Purina Pro Plan Senior and Hill’s Science Diet Senior satisfy these requirements. Consult your vet for breed and health-specific needs.
Best Dog Food for Weight Loss
Does your dog need to slim down? Weight management diets deliver lower fat and calories with extra nutrients. Here’s what to seek:
- 10% or less fat – Compared to around 20% in regular foods. Leans meats, veggie fats.
- Beet pulp – Boosts fullness and reduces appetite.
- Added L-carnitine – Helps burn fat.
- Increased fiber – Also enhances satiety and digestion. Barley, peas.
- Lower carbs – Limit high glycemic carbs that spike blood sugar.
- More protein – Builds and preserves lean muscle mass that burns calories.
- Omega fatty acids – Support metabolism. Salmon, canola oils.
- An optimal moisture blend – Mix of wet and dry food gives satisfy without excess calories.
Top choices for weight control are Blue Buffalo Healthy Weight Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe, Wellness Core Reduced Fat Formula, Nutro Ultra Weight Management and Purina Pro Plan Weight Management.
Best Dog Food for Sensitive Stomachs
Does your dog suffer from digestive woes and stomach sensitivity? Here’s how to pick the perfect food to ease tummy troubles:
- Limited ingredient diet – Avoiding trigger ingredients minimizes allergic reactions. Novel proteins like duck, salmon.
- Single protein and carbohydrate source – Less likely to cause issues than blends. Ex: lamb and rice.
- Probiotics – Boost healthy gut flora. Look for foods containing live cultures.
- Prebiotics – Provide “fuel” probiotics need. Chicory root, beet pulp.
- Pumpkin – Soothes stomach upset and aids digestion. Added to many sensitive stomach formulas.
- Omega fatty acids – Reduce inflammation in the GI tract. Fish, flax oils.
- Zinc, vitamin E and carotenoids – Support intestinal health and nutrient absorption.
Purina Pro Plan Sensitive Skin and Stomach Salmon & Rice Formula, Hill’s Science Diet Sensitive Stomach & Skin and Natural Balance L.I.D. Limited Ingredient Diets Sweet Potato & Fish are excellent options.
Best Dog Food for Skin Allergies
If skin allergies or itchiness plagues your pup, you can provide relief through diet. Optimal food choices include:
- Limited ingredients – Avoiding common triggers like chicken, grains cuts allergic reactions. Unique proteins like duck, venison.
- Omegas 3 and 6 fatty acids – Anti-inflammatory effects decrease skin irritation. Fish, flaxseed oils.
- Vitamins E and C – Potent antioxidants protect skin.
- Zinc and biotin – Support skin integrity and coat health.
- Prebiotics and probiotics – Lessen inflammation and boost immune response.
- No artificial additives – Chemicals like colors and preservatives can trigger flareups.
Purina Pro Plan Sensitive Skin and Stomach Salmon & Rice Formula, Nutro Limited Ingredient Diet Venison Meal & Sweet Potato Recipe, and Natural Balance L.I.D. Limited Ingredient Diets Lamb Meal & Brown Rice Formula earn top marks.
For best results, partner with both your vet and pet nutritionist to pinpoint and eliminate allergy triggers.
Dog Food for Specific Health Conditions
If your dog suffers from certain health conditions, specialized food can go a long way in managing symptoms.
Look for reduced protein, phosphorus and sodium levels. Increased omega fatty acids and antioxidants.
Hill’s Science Diet Kidney Care Chicken & Vegetable Stew
Subscribe to our list
Don't worry, we don't spam
Grain-free low glycemic carbs. Higher protein and fat. Added fiber like metformin. Antioxidants.
Purina Pro Plan Diabetes Management
Ultra low fat around 10%. Easily digestible carbs like white rice. Soluble fiber. Antioxidants. Omegas.
Royal Canin Veterinary Diet Gastrointestinal Low Fat LF
Urinary Tract Stones
Restrict oxalates, and calcium. Reduce urinary mineral crystals. Increased moisture.
Hill’s Prescription Diet c/d Multicare Urinary Care Chicken & Vegetable Stew
- Glucosamine – Rebuilds cartilage
- Chondroitin – Prevents cartilage breakdown
- Omega fatty acids – Reduce inflammation
- Antioxidants – Protect joints
Hill’s Science Diet Joint Care Chicken Meal, Barley & Vegetable Recipe
- Taurine – Supports heart function
- L-carnitine – Helps heart metabolism
- Omega fatty acids – Improve circulation
- CoQ10 – Boosts cardiac health
Purina Pro Plan Veterinary Diets HF Hydrolyzed Protein Formula
- Novel proteins – Venison, duck, kangaroo
- Carbs like sweet potato, chickpeas
- Limited ingredients – For easier diagnosis
Natural Balance L.I.D. Limited Ingredient Diets Sweet Potato & Venison Formula
- Antioxidants – Protect neurons
- Omega fatty acids – Support cognitive function
- B vitamins – Aid nerve function
- Vegetable sources – For mental sharpness
Hill’s Prescription Diet b/d Brain Health Chicken & Vegetable Stew
6 FAQs About the Healthiest Dog Food Choices
1. Is it okay to feed my dog people food?
Feeding table scraps can disrupt your dog’s balanced diet and lead to weight gain or nutritional deficiencies over time. Better options are giving healthy snacks like small pieces of cooked chicken breast, plain yogurt, or apples versus human junk foods.
2. How do I transition my dog to a new food?
Mix a small amount like 25% of the new food with 75% of the old food. Gradually transition over 5-7 days until completely switched to avoid GI upset.
3. Should I look for organic dog food?
While organic is appealing, what matters most is the overall recipe and quality ingredients regardless of organic status. Don’t assume organic is automatically healthier.
4. Is raw dog food better than commercial diets?
Proponents believe raw food is closer to a natural ancestral diet. But improperly handled raw ingredients pose major bacterial risks. Most vets don’t recommend exclusively raw diets, noting commercial foods provide balanced nutrition that’s been safety tested.
5. Should I cook food for my dog?
While fresh whole foods can be healthy supplemental mix-ins, creating a complete and balanced homecooked diet is extremely difficult. Work closely with a vet nutritionist to formulate recipes ensuring all your dog’s nutritional needs are met if going this route. Most dogs thrive on quality commercial diets without the need for cooking.
6. How can I compare brands when ingredients vary?
Focus first on main components: named meat protein source, whole food carbs, healthy fats, etc. Verify there’s no cheap fillers or artificial additives. Then look for optimal levels of key items like protein, fat, carbs for your dog’s needs and preferences. Ingredient differences between high-quality brands are minor.
The Bottom Line
Choosing the healthiest dog food ultimately requires:
- Reading labels closely
- Analyzing ingredients
- Researching companies
- Understanding your dog’s needs
- Consulting veterinary experts
Put in the work upfront to find the ideal diet. Your dog will thrive with the right nutrition tailored just for them!